New York Take and Bake Pizza Co. of Utah opened a new location in Sugar House just before Christmas.
You can find them at 675 E 2100 S next to Kid to Kid off of 700 East. They also have a location in Fort Union.
You can order by phone (801-487-6591), online or by their app (search New York Take and it pulls up). They make it fresh, customized for you, then just stop by to pick it up and bake it at home.
You’re probably wondering how this place is different than the other take and bake pizza place in the neighborhood. Well, New York Take & Bake is locally owned and operated. It has some similar items to the chain but there are more unique specialty pizzas and a larger variety of salads, not to mention flavored Italian sodas.
Their ingredients are all fresh and locally sourced. They don’t get their food off a truck like other chain restaurants. They have five different salads to choose from. My family loved the pasta salad. I normally try to make a salad at home to go along with our pizza when we order it, but at this price ($6-$7/fed 4 of us) it is much cheaper than if I bought all the ingredients myself (and much tastier). I want to try their spinach poppy seed salad next. I would order these just to go with other meals at home or grab one to split for lunch.
We tried the Margherita and the Chicken BLT pizzas. Instructions say to cook them until lightly brown on the edges and top of cheese. It turned out just right. The Margherita has huge slices of mozarella and had a sweet, tangy sauce. The Chicken BLT has the alfredo sauce and bacon. You had me at Bacon! The touches of spinach and feta really set this apart.
All their pizzas have the New York style thin crusts. The owner, John, has owned and cooked at the Italian restaurant, Michelangelo’s for 11 years. He grew up just outside of New York City and has always loved thin crust pizza. He started developing new recipes and tried them out with friends and family and finally decided to create the New York Take & Bake Pizza Co. They opened in Fort Union early last year and have done well so they recently started the Sugar House location.
Stop by and tell them I Heart Salt Lake sent you and you’ll get 10% off your order. Say hi to the owners, John & Katie.
Follow NYT&B on Facebook and Instagram for daily or weekly special deals. They also accept EBT.
Sugar House: 675 East 2100 South
Salt Lake City, Utah
Fort Union: 2416 East Ft. Union Blvd.
Salt Lake City, Utah
Disclosure: We were given some pizzas, salad and Italian sodas for review purposes only. All opinions are 100% my own. Try it for yourself.